Home | Blog

Amazon's Luna Controller is about what you would expect

I accidentally reviewed Amazon's Luna Controller and the game streaming service it belongs to

08 Feb 2021

Images on this page are low resolution to save bandwidth, click them for full size versions

Videos on this page are represented by thumbnails, click them to watch

This post is adapted from a Twitter thread I wrote on February 4th and 5th, 2021


Just got my Luna controller and was surprised to see they didn't just go with a regular box

Amazon Luna controller in its trapezoidal box

It feels small even though it's about the same size as an Xbox series controller? The sticks are much lighter gray than I expected. Grips have a pretty neat texture. Face buttons are completely flat. LT, RT, LB, and RB have the biggest labels I've ever seen.

Luna controller in hand Back side of Luna controller grip showing texture Luna controller face buttons Top of Luna controller showing very large trigger and bumper labels

Triggers are very shallow when compared to most other controllers. Almost comparable to the Steam controller? The cluster of buttons in the middle don't feel like they're using a membrane, they're closer to joycon buttons. Luna button feels extremely shallow. Dpad just feels sad.

Luna controller with one trigger held Xbox series controller with one trigger held Steam controller with one trigger held

Battery cover has a piece of foam on it. Home/Luna button uses addressable RGB LEDs similar to an Echo so it can do different colors and animations. Looks nice.

Luna controller battery cover Luna controller in setup (circling orange light) Luna controller connecting to wifi (purple light moving from bottom to top) Luna controller connecting to wifi (purple light moving from bottom to top)

When in game the top part of the circle is solid purple. Blue tones are exaggerated in this picture, it's much more gentle in person.

Luna controller in game (top of circle lit solid purple)

Luna has a unique mouse cursor... that isn't going away when I use the controller

Luna's mouse cursor, a partially transparent purple circle with a white border and a white dot in the middle

Input latency is a thing. Action on button release. Can't figure out how to use the 1/8x speed video I took lol

Thumbnail of a video demonstrating Luna's input latency in Grid

There we are. Sound looks out of sync, don't trust it. 1/8x speed, action on button release.

Thumbnail of a slow motion video demonstrating Luna's input latency in Grid

Latency could depend on the game. First tests were in Grid, this is in Lumines Remastered. 1/8x speed, action on button press this time. Still don't trust the sound. No mouse cursor issues in this game.

Thumbnail of a slow motion video demonstrating Luna's input latency in Lumines Remastered

Rumble isn't bad on the controller. Using rotating mass vibrators instead of Switch style LRAs but it's not overpowering or too weak.

Unlike Stadia, the controller disconnects when you're not in a game (on desktop at least). It stays on but you can't use it to navigate the menus.

Input latency in Control is pretty bad. Video is full speed, action on button press.

Thumbnail of a video demonstrating Luna's input latency in Control

Keyboard comparison. Video full speed, action on keypress.

Thumbnail of a video demonstrating Luna's input latency in Control

Not sure if the audio on these is synced or not but our brains are weird anyway and interpret vision and hearing with different delays so just go by sight

This isn't a connection speed thing btw. Will compare to Stadia later. Reminder that Luna is still in beta and things are expected to change before release.

Screenshot from speedtest.net showing 13ms ping, 100.11Mbps download, and 5.86Mbps upload

I saw some Xbox colored button prompts earlier but didn't want to jump to conclusions. This button prompt is Xbox specific though, so we can safely guess that these games are accepting Luna controller input as if it's an Xbox controller.

Xbox recents/back/"box box" button prompt

Smart move by Amazon to minimize friction for game developers but it's kinda weird when the corresponding button has a circle on it. Manual calls if the action button.

Front of Luna controller showing the center button cluster Luna controller manual showing what all the buttons are called

While I have the box off the shelf, here's the back of the Luna controller box and the back of the Stadia premiere edition box. Just a little similar lol

Back of Luna controller box: "For the love of play" with a picture of the Luna controller
Back of Stadia premiere edition box: "One place for all the ways we play."

Well this is a little confusing. Pretty sure the game crashed.

Luna claiming "connection terminated due to poor network" and "something went wrong on our end" at the same time

Got caught up playing Control and didn't get to the Stadia comparison lol. Will test both tomorrow so network conditions aren't different between the tests.

Stadia input latency in Doom 2016, video 1/8x speed, action on button press, don't trust the desynced audio

Thumbnail of a slow motion video demonstrating Stadia's input latency in Doom 2016

Luna input latency in Control retested for a fair comparison, video 1/8x speed, action on button press, don't trust the desynced audio

Thumbnail of a slow motion video demonstrating Luna's input latency in Control